“Contrary
to conventional wisdom, ethnic unity has not produced the peaceful
coexistence of the two Koreas, but instead has provoked a half century of
intense conflict and tension” (Shin: 156). This is very obviously shown in the
movie Welcome to Dongmakgol. One
scene to back this theory up is when the soldiers from North and South Korea
first met each other in the village of Dongmakgol and the tension created
between them. Although the soldiers are both from the peninsula of Korea, have
the same ancestral background, look alike and speak the same language, this
intense conflict created by the politics of North and South Korea made the
soldiers very hostile towards each other. Because of the difference of their
uniforms, they did not want to live together or work together. However, as the
soldiers passed time in Dongmakgol, they began to separate themselves from the
antagonistic war between the North and the South, gradually realizing that they
are one and the same. For this reason and with the help of the villagers of
Dongmakgol, it caused the five soldiers to work together in the end as one team
to save Dongmakgol. This proves a point: hostility and division are not really
ignited by the soldiers themselves and has nothing to do with the nationalistic
belief; the opposing North and South Korean governments propagandize everything
and it is them that create opposition. Perhaps many soldiers of the Korean War
do not know what they were fighting for; maybe they did not even understand the
concept of nationalism and were forced to stand in battle. Eliminating the
outside influence, North Koreans and South Koreans can still work towards the
same goal and fight for the same cause. Ethnic unity should be divided into two
aspects: the unity of government and the unity of the people. Welcome to Dongmakgol proves to us that
without government control. ethnic unity is not only possible, but also a
powerful force.
Hmmm, I'm not sure I understand whether you are agreeing or disagreeing with Shin, then. It's difficult to separate the "people" from "the government," especially during the formative, post-liberation period, before the consolidation of the North and South Korean states, the DPRK and the ROK.
ReplyDeleteI agree that it is hard to separate the people from the government during that period, but if we just look at the context of the movie it showed that it was indeed possible to fight against the same thing even if they were on opposing sides. Movie-wise, it seemed like the it was the government that were controlling them, a couple of the soldiers didn't even know what they were fighting for. I just found that aspect really interesting.
Delete